Cinder by Marissa Meyer {Amanda’s Reviews}

Posted 26 November, 2012 by Amanda / 37 Comments

Cinder by Marissa Meyer {Amanda’s Reviews}Cinder by Marissa Meyer
Series: Lunar Chronicles #1
Also in this series: Scarlet, Cress, Fairest, Cinder (The Lunar Chronicles, #1), Winter
Genres: Fairy Tales & Folklore, Science Fiction, Young Adult
Pages: 448
Format: Hardcover
Source: Purchased

Humans and androids crowd the raucous streets of New Beijing. A deadly plague ravages the population. From space, a ruthless lunar people watch, waiting to make their move. No one knows that Earth’s fate hinges on one girl. . . .

Cinder, a gifted mechanic, is a cyborg. She’s a second-class citizen with a mysterious past, reviled by her stepmother and blamed for her stepsister’s illness. But when her life becomes intertwined with the handsome Prince Kai’s, she suddenly finds herself at the center of an intergalactic struggle, and a forbidden attraction. Caught between duty and freedom, loyalty and betrayal, she must uncover secrets about her past in order to protect her world’s future.

 Needed Scarlet immediately upon finishing Cinder.

My Thoughts on Cinder

My original interest in this book really only came about because Marissa Meyer was at a signing with Leigh Bardugo (whose book I wanted). I knew others had loved Cinder, but I wasn’t really sure it would be my thing. (Cyborgs? Ehhh. Fairy tale retelling? Meh.) Wrong. WRONG! Oh, was I ever WRONG. Cinder hit all the right spots for me, and had me staying up until 1am in the morning to finish the book during a reading slump.

If, like me, you turn your nose up a little at cyborgs, stop. Sometimes I can be kind of an ass about my reading preferences. The conversation in my head goes something like, “Cyborgs? Pooh. No. Fairy tale retelling? Pooh. No.” Well, I’m an idiot. I should not have pooh-poohed this book, because it rocked me out of a reading slump and that’s something that isn’t easy to do. Whatever I thought I didn’t like about cyborgs or fairy tale retellings was a bunch of mumbo jumbo. In fact, as I found myself talking with the boyfriend about this book, I realized it was one of those rare books that actually got a “Cool” response from him rather than a polite “yes, I’m listening to you ramble about books I don’t care about” nod. Cyborgs are cool, y’all.

Unless, of course, you’re a cyborg in New Beijing. Then you’re not cool; you are considered a sub-standard creature. I actually enjoyed this aspect. A lot. Human society has always been plagued by the desire to oppress one group to prove the superiority of another (i.e., you can’t be superior if everyone is equal). Setting up Cinder as a cyborg was a good parallel to the actual Cinderella story, and it also gave the book an added element of tension and suspense. Cinder may be a retelling, but Marissa Meyer has woven such a unique story that it only builds on the original and creates something that is completely its own.

While there were certain aspects of the plot and book that were relatively predictable, I found that this was no real detriment to the overall story. I mean, come on. It’s a retelling. The plot has to go a certain way, you know? And you have to have elements of the story that hold somewhat true to the original story. I enjoyed watching how Cinder discovered these parts that were obvious to me as a reader. I wanted to find out how it all fit together at the end. Reading this was like putting together a puzzle. We know what the puzzle should look like, but the individual pieces are new and somewhat unfamiliar to us. With each piece we add to the puzzle, our excitement builds; we want to see how our individual pieces turn into the full picture.

What did shock me about Cinder, however, was the ending. My word, THE ENDING destroyed me. Not because of what happened, mind you, but because of where it ended. I got all flaily and needed Scarlet RIGHT AWAY. So, in short: Cinder rocked. Don’t let your preconceived notions stop you from considering this book. It is more than a retelling; it is more than a story about cyborgs. And I loved it. *flails*


Filed under: ESR: 9, Review: Amanda, Science Fiction, YA, ,


37 Responses to “Cinder by Marissa Meyer {Amanda’s Reviews}”

  1. I was exactly the same about Cinder. I had seen it on so many people’s blogs, but wasn’t that interested. Then I found it in a Dutch bookstore, read the first page and was immediately hooked. I can’t wait for Scarlet to come out (:

  2. Agreed. Even though you know most of where the book will go, it was still fresh and a joy to follow. I was lucky enough to have the audiobook. The narrator really added that extra magic making it feel like it was playing out on the big screen. The Ending!!!! Scarlett is coming soon. ;D

  3. CINDER most definitely did ROCK — and SCARLET is one I begged the publisher for (and most likely won’t get…oh well. I’ll just have to wait with bated breath!). Love how there’s the cyborg twist and the subtle fairy tale elements woven throughout. Masterfully done.

  4. I honestly had no intention of reading this one. I think it’s on my TBR list – but it’s so low on the priority list that I’d never get there. But you just brought it way up to the top. It might even get read in the next few weeks thanks to this review!

  5. Sounds like a great book. Funny, I just finished reading a review copy of a fairy tale as well for a book blog hop. I’ve really never seen much about books like this and then I read one & you write this glowing review. Thanks for posting. I will have to put this on my “to read” list.

    Paul R. Hewlett

  6. I totally poohed this book when I first heard about it. I mean a cyborg Cinderella? Could it really work? I was scared it would go all techie on me and I would have no clue, but I was very wrong and pleasantly surprised by this. I didn’t think the ending was a huge cliffhanger, but I’m definitely curious to see how everything works out especially given with 2 other fairy tale heroines introduced.

  7. “I realized it was one of those rare books that actually got a “Cool” response from him rather than a polite “yes, I’m listening to you ramble about books I don’t care about” nod. Cyborgs are cool, y’all.”

    Now if that’s not the mark of a winner of a book, I don’t know what is:) Also, I love that you used the world “flaily” when describing the end of Cinder. Win. Wasn’t this one fabulous? I so adored and I definitely had a minor freak out when I reached the end and realized there was no more for me to read. I can’t wait for Scarlet. I need it immediately:)

    • Yes! If my non-reader boyfriend can be interested in the book, that’s a win in my book.

      I was so flaily at the end of this book, Jenny! The ending caught me by surprise and it was the middle of the night when I finished and I just… flailed all over the place.

  8. Like I told you before, I started this, but put it down around the 50 page mark — not because it was bad, but I just wasn’t in the mood. After your review I need to pick it up again! Even if that’s just to know what this ending is! :)

    • I actually finished Cinder in the middle of a reading slump, so I think that says something. But if you’re not in the mood, it’s probably not something that should be forced. (It’s good, though. I promise.)

  9. I love flaily Amanda. I’m sad that I still haven’t read this one, but it does sound damn interesting. Bring on the cyborgs and oppression, I say! I’m glad it brought you out of a reading slump. No fun, those.


    I can’t even explain how happy it makes me that you loved this. And loved it so much you got flaily.


    It’s… I don’t know. Despite being a self-professed sci-fi nerd, I wasn’t interested in this. Despite the 5 star reviews, and the opinions of all my fave bloggers saying it was amazing, I wasn’t interested. And then I read it.

    And… I was so surprised at… well, what you said: how much more it was. It’s not just cyborgs, and it’s not just a fairytale retelling, and OMFG. AMANDA. THE DEPTH. I was surprised at how much… more this book was than I expected it would or COULD be and I’M SO EXCITED YOU LOVED IT ♥

  11. I thought the same thing as well! I absolutely LOVEDCinder!! I loved the way it was retold but also how it was its own world as well! I didn’t know I was going to love it so much, I stayed up even later than you, 3AM!!! And yes, the ending… OH MY GOD, LOL.

  12. I didn’t realise the last two titles in the series had been released already!

    I really need to get round to reading this – I’ve had it on my TBR since… I don’t know, March? I’ve never heard a single negative thing about it, but other books kept getting in the way.

    • Scarlet doesn’t come out until next year. I think I neglected to add in all the release dates on my book order. *head desk*

      This was on my TBR list for quite some time, too. I would have kept passing it over, too, if it hadn’t been for Kelly. I’m glad I picked it up!

  13. OMG – I had not a clue that you poo-poohed this one! I’m so stoked it got you jazzed about books again. I had no clue about the ending and if I had known, I probably wouldn’t have read it just on that notion – I hate those endings. B/C I completely and utterly flailed right there with you! And that was almost a whole year ago.

    I totally loved this book, though!!! But there was plenty of WTF-ing going on in the house the day I ended the story…

    Awesome, awesome review!!!